Should We Stop Teaching Humanities

GlobalMindsetWhen I was in school and had to make a choice in class ten about which subject to pursue, the decision was easy. There were three reasons why I would never get to study Science. They were Physics, Chemistry and Biology. I wanted to study Humanities. My seniors all said the same thing, “There is no scope in Humanities” and while I did not know what that meant, it sounded scary. Besides they did not offer it as an option in my school. Reluctantly, I studied Commerce for my last two years in school. Reading about history, philosophy and literature was left to me.The situation is not very different today. Education, especially college is getting limited to becoming the few years one wastes before getting employed. So there is a great degree of emphasis in ensuring that graduation and post-graduation should prepare the student to become employable. There is nothing wrong in that aim, except that the employers increasingly do not find the freshly minted college hires employable. 47% graduates not employable in any sector of the knowledge economy according to a survey done by Aspiring Minds. The report is alarming:

“The employability of graduates varies from 2.59 per cent in functional roles such as accounting, to 15.88 per cent in sales related roles and 21.37 per cent for roles in the business process outsourcing (BPO/ITeS) sector. A significant proportion of graduates, nearly 47 per cent, were found not employable in any sector, given their insufficient English language and cognitive skills.”

The ability to articulate ideas in conversations and in writing hugely impacts a person’s success in the knowledge economy. Information is commoditized. We can always “Google” what we don’t know. The real skill then is about knowing how to ask the right question. To be able to contextualize that information and influence others is a vital element that is lost.The trend is not limited to India. It is a worldwide trend. Studying literature and philosophy is seen to be a detour. We live in a world that is more volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous (VUCA). There are rarely any straight answers to questions. It is important that people learn to deal with shades of grey by sorting out conflicting issues and making better choices – skills that humanities offer. These are skills that are equally important to engineers and scientists as they are to business leaders.  No wonder that MIT runs a “Charm School” for aspiring engineers to help them develop effective communications skills to foster success in interviewing and adjusting to corporate life.Recent findings show that reading literary fiction (not pop fiction) helps people build their empathy and emotional intelligence. It is the ability to manage one’s emotions and understand others emotions that makes people successful. Successful people understand not just what to say, but also understand when to say it and how to articulate the same idea that some else fumbled with. When is a person listening to your point of view and when are they mentally bracing themselves to demolish your view point? How to tell somebody something they’d rather not hear. Humanities teach us to deal with shades of grey (not just the Fifty Shades) that life offers every day. Human beings are complex creatures. The same scenario may get us to react differently depending on how we are feeling. Siblings brought up in the same environment turn out to be different from each other. Liberal Arts tell us how to make the world fit for humans.Join me on twitter @AbhijitBhaduri

Share the Post:

5 Comments

  1. monica says:

    Science/ commerce  subjects are comparatively precise and requires memory , mathametical skills and analytical skills wheras humanities require communications , thinking and understanding skills .We are  somewhat lost if knowledge / ideas are poorly conveyed . the emotional intelligence imparted by humanities is invaluable in work and life .

  2. Jay Menon says:

    I have often seen how those who are considered to be the best and have graduated from the Ivy leagues have failed to make it successful in the real world. I am not referring to money, but being creative, innovating and the ability to connect with others without the thought of the element ” I”. There is a growing sense in the academia that humanities and music help people see beyond the “numbers”.CheersJay

  3. monica says:

    I often wondered if it is possible to be good at both science / commerce and humanities .Apparently we are born with eigher a left dominated brain or right . apparently left dominated ones are more artistic .If you are naturally talented in scientific subjects but not care much for literature or music , can you be taught to be good at them ?I suppose that is where good teachers come in . i suppose you can be inspired to learn , to think and communicate . Lucky are those who get someone to teach them early on in their life .

  4. Abhijit Bhaduri says:

    One can be good at almost anything. The way one is taught a subject can make all the difference. The role of a teacher is to enhance capability and also to spark motivation to work hard and become better.

  5. VK Shrotryia says:

    One can not ever think of education without humanities, without liberal arts. Much of what Abhijit is writing here happened with me, though I was inclined to do literature or philosophy or psychology, I was put to study Commerce (many reasons and not at all that I was poor in my studies).I feel that the major reason for our graduates not being employable is that their exposure, articulation and understanding is poor.It is generally felt that the best students choose Engg or Medical (though medical is losing charm) and since they get focused on their respective field of study that they get trapped into the Instant Mix culture which somehow takes their vices away from being a humane person. Liberal arts bridge that gap and develop their creativity and imagination power which I feel is more important. I am so happy to see this write up which is much as per what I have been thinking. Thanx Abhijit…wishesvijay

Leave a Reply to Jay Menon Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Because We Don’t ONLY Measure Work By Speed of Completion

Because Humanoid Robots Are Faster Than Humans

AI Is Warping Your Sense of Time at Work